On 8 July 2022, at about ten at night and some 80 nautical miles east of Gloucester, Massachusetts, USA, the engine room bilge alarms sounded aboard the stern trawler Grace Marie. The captain closed the seacocks and started every bilge pump aboard, and the water rose anyway. The crew of seven put on immersion suits and stepped straight into the liferaft. Within minutes the fishing vessel Dawn T was alongside, and nobody was hurt. Grace Marie was presumed sunk and never salvaged.
She was built in 1978 of quarter-inch steel. Eight to ten years before she sank, her owner had 3/8-inch doubler plates welded along each side of the keel, because the steel there was "a little spotty". Under the engine room, the captain told investigators, "it was all [doubler] plate." A surveyor recorded those doublers in a condition and valuation survey in 2018, which found the hull in overall good condition for her age. She was hauled out again in 2021, and drydocked four months before she sank. The National Transportation Safety Board could not say for certain where the water came in. It gave the likely cause as a failure of the doubler-plated hull below the engine room, and made a point about the repair that applies to every inspection she had: doubler plating "inhibits the ability to assess the true condition of the hull".1
A North Atlantic trawler is a long way from a canal boat. The repair is the same, and on the canals it is called overplating. It is a long-established inland repair, insurers cover overplated boats, and at least one has required overplating as a condition of cover.2 What it changes is the evidence. From outside, the gauge reads the repair, and the plate behind it can be measured only from inside or known from records. So the report records an overplated area as a repair with its own history: described, dated and bounded, with what could not be established said plainly. This builds on our narrowboat survey primer and is the companion to the steel-hull thickness post, which covers the gauge and the reading grid.
Which Repair Is It?
Overplating, also called doubling, welds new plate over the old and leaves the old in place: on the sides, across the baseplate, or both. Replating crops the wasted plate out, back to sound steel, and welds a new insert into the gap. Isolated deep pits can instead be built up with weld metal, with the area cleaned and dried first.2 The words are used loosely, and "replated" or "new baseplate" in sale particulars can describe an overplate, so the report names the repair it found and the evidence for it.
Overplating keeps the hot work outside and in shorter runs, so the cabin lining can usually stay in place, which is much of its appeal. The heat still passes through the original plate to whatever is bonded to its inside face, spray foam included, so scorched foam behind an edge is worth looking for wherever the inside can be seen. Replating a side usually means taking out the lining behind it, both to weld the insert and to protect the foam.
Ship repair takes a firmer view. IACS Recommendation 47, the classification societies' repair standard, allows a local doubler on hull plating normally only as a temporary repair, with slot welds to tie a larger one to the plate behind,3 and the NTSB and the US Coast Guard advise cropping out wasted steel and inserting new plate.1 Those rules are written for ships and do not reach a private boat on the cut, where, as one inland discussion paper puts it, the surveyor is "presently at liberty" to choose the method.2 Their concerns carry over all the same: the original is hidden, water can get between the plates, and a large plate held only at its edges can flex. The report records which repair is there, how it was done, and what it lets the surveyor establish.
What the Gauge Reads
From outside, the gauge reads the overplate. The gap between the plates, often holding rust or water, returns the echo, so the back wall the gauge finds is the inner face of the new plate. Read clear of the welds, and label every reading on an overplated area as a reading of the overplate.
Overplating announces itself in other ways: the stepped fillet weld along its edge, which can be seen and felt, the dimples of plug welds, and a step in the readings, with uniform near-new figures inside the band and older, pitted figures outside it. A reading well above anything the build could explain is first a question for the gauge (its velocity setting, its calibration, its mode) and then a reason to look for an edge.
The original plate can be measured from inside, wherever the engine-bay bilge, the lockers, the ballast and the linings let a probe onto it, and a few internal readings behind the band tell the surveyor more than any number of external ones. Spray foam stops internal readings, and so does poured-concrete ballast over a baseplate; record both, zone by zone. Lifting boards, ballast or a lining panel takes the vendor's consent, so where no internal reading was possible on the day, say so and give the buyer the choice: targeted access with consent, or the uncertainty stated plainly enough to price.
Readings of the original plate outside the band, above the top edge and beyond each end, describe the hull there. That plate has spent less of its life wet than the plate the overplate covers, so it does not stand in for it, and the report says so.
The hammer adds indirect evidence. A dull or drumming note across an overplate shows where the plates have parted, where the original has gone, or where rust and water sit between them, and pillowing between welds shows rust forcing them apart. Keeling and Brookes make satisfactory hammer sounding one of the conditions for accepting plate near their proposed minimum.2
Read the overplate itself with care, since its readings are the next survey's baseline. New plate can read under its nominal thickness and still sit within its rolling tolerance, so thinning is judged against earlier recorded readings. An overplate losing steel at the rate the original did says the cause is still at work: tired or painted-over anodes, galvanic current through a shore-power earth with no isolator, or stray current from the boat's own wiring. The battery and shore power entry covers each of them.
Reading the Edges
The edges are where an overplate shows its workmanship, and where trouble shows first. Before she comes out, look in the bilges: water there, afloat, is the only direct evidence of whether anything is coming in. Then walk every edge and seam, port and starboard, and record:
- whether the edge welds and the welds between sheets run continuously, or are stitched or tacked with gaps that let water between the plates;
- pinholes or cracks in any weld, and cracking from square corners;
- plug or slot welds across a large plate, usual on a baseplate overplate, where they hold it to the steel behind across its area;
- where the top edge sits, measured from a fixed point such as the gunwale, since ashore the waterline is only a fouling mark;
- how the overplate meets the swims, the stem and every outlet it is cut round, and whether the anodes are welded to the overplate or the original;
- rust runs, weeps or lifting blacking along a seam, and water draining from an edge after lift-out. Water that drains from a seam was between the plates.
A baseplate overplate also covers the baseplate lip and the original chine weld, so the record describes how the new edge is finished at the chine. The blocks hide what they sit on, and access to base plating is often poor in a dock, so the report says where the blocks were and what could not be reached.2 The original baseplate can waste from inside as well, under the ballast, where it is out of sight from both directions.
Recording a Replate
A replate leaves a single skin the gauge can read, so its record is simpler. Give the extent of each insert, the date and the yard, and the condition of the butt welds, checked from inside where they can be reached. Read the insert and the original plate beside it, since an insert is only as sound as the steel it was welded into. Note whether the coating and insulation inside were put back afterwards.
The Paperwork, the Weight and the Quote
Ask for the paperwork. A yard's invoice or job sheet should give the date, the plate and its thickness, the extent, whether holes in the original were welded first, and whether the original was cleaned and coated before it was covered. The best evidence of what lies behind an overplate is a set of readings taken before it went on, and the survey that prompted the work often has them. Where none of this exists, the report says so.
Weight deserves a line. Take a 57ft boat with about 26 square metres of baseplate. A 6mm overplate across it is about 1.2 tonnes of steel, and she floats about 3.5cm lower for it, drawing about 4cm more.4 That is modest, and worth a look at anything already close to the waterline: the gas locker drain outlets, which the Boat Safety Scheme expects above the normal laden waterline (our LPG post has the detail), the self-draining well-deck and cockpit drains, the weed hatch and the exhaust. A side overplate's top edge sits that much nearer the water too. If ballast was lifted to make up the difference, the record says so.
Where the report recommends work, its record shapes the quote. A yard prices the extent (baseplate, sides or both), the plate thickness, how the boat is lifted or docked, whether linings must come out for a replate, and the blacking afterwards. A mapped extent and stated readings let a yard quote like for like, and let an owner weigh a replate against an overplate on the same terms.
Insurers set their own rules. When Keeling and Brookes asked four inland insurers, one expected 4mm on base plates, one required 4mm on all hull plating and had required 3mm Springers to be overplated before it would cover them, one relied on the surveyor's judgement, and one stipulated 4mm without saying why.2 Record overplating so that whichever rule an insurer applies, it can apply it from the report. The Boat Safety Scheme examination does not measure the hull, so a current certificate says nothing about overplating either way, as our BSS and pre-purchase post sets out. Hull condition also drives a narrowboat's value, so the valuer reads the same record.
Grading It
Grade the defects. A sound overplate is a repair, so it is recorded as an observation, with its baseline readings and its "not established" statement, and it stays out of the defect schedule. Square corners and a narrow side band without slot welds are noted as they are found. What is wrong in or around an overplate is graded in the usual Category A, B and C way.
Category A. Water coming in through an overplate or its welds, seen afloat; an overplate perforated; and any breach below the waterline (a pinhole or crack in a weld, or water draining from a seam after lift-out) where the plate behind cannot be shown sound. Behind a breach the original may be the only watertight skin left, or may be gone. Rectify before she is refloated, draining and drying the gap before the weld is made good.
Category B. Edges stitched or tacked, with gaps in the seal; pinholes, cracks or weeps above the waterline; drumming or pillowing over an area; a large baseplate overplate with no plug welds; an overplate pitted, or thinning against earlier recorded readings at a rate that would reach the insurer's threshold before the next survey. Put right at this lift-out where the work allows, while she is out of the water, or within a stated period.
Category C. Blacking lifting along an edge; light surface rust on a top-edge weld above the waterline. Maintain, and re-read at the next survey.
Documenting It
Inadequate: "Hull sides overplated. UTT 4.9 to 5.3mm. Satisfactory."
Professional: "Observation. Overplating, port and starboard sides, from the baseplate lip to 180mm below the gunwale, counter to 1.5m aft of the stem; 5mm plate, fitted March 2019, according to the yard's invoice supplied by the vendor. Edge welds continuous; corners square, no cracking seen; no slot welds, as expected on a band this narrow. Baseplate original. External UTT, multiple-echo, 60 points on the overplate: 4.9 to 5.3mm, recorded as readings of the overplate and as the baseline for the next survey. Original plate above the top edge and forward of the overplate, 24 points: 5.1 to 5.8mm; these do not establish the covered plate. Hammer sounding even along the band, except at the defect below. Bilges dry afloat before lift-out. Original plate behind the overplate not established: linings and spray foam throughout, the engine-bay side plate foamed as well, and no readings from before the overplating available.
Category A. Pinhole in the lower edge weld at the chine, starboard quarter, about 2m forward of the counter, below the waterline, with rust staining, water draining from it after lift-out and a dull note under the hammer over about 300mm around it. Water has been between the plates, and the plate behind cannot be shown sound. Recommend, before she is refloated, that the gap be drained and dried, the weld ground out and re-made, and the area re-gauged; and, with the vendor's consent, that one lining panel be opened and the foam cut back locally to read the original plate behind this area. Photographs attached."
The second record names the repair and its history, gives the readings layer by layer, states what was not established and why, and keeps the observation apart from the graded defect. Our post on what makes a survey report defensible explains why a "not established" clause carries as much weight as a finding. On an overplated hull it is often the most important sentence in the hull section.
Marine Inspect's narrowboat templates give the steel hull a section of its own. The hull thickness item asks for readings by named hull zone, with any zone that spray foam put out of reach flagged as unassessable; the pre-purchase template adds an item for previous patches, over-painting and concealed corrosion repairs; and the valuation template asks for recent significant works, hull replating among them. The surveyor's readings, grades and photographs go against those items and carry into the report. The Meadow Lark narrowboat sample shows a hull record in full, including the plain statement that no patches, overplating or concealed repairs were found.
Footnotes
-
National Transportation Safety Board, Flooding and Sinking of Fishing Vessel Grace Marie, Marine Investigation Report MIR-23-13 (16 June 2023), investigation DCA22FM027. It sets out the vessel's build (1978, steel), the 2018 condition and valuation survey with bottom survey, which recorded the 1/4-inch hull plate and the 3/8-inch doublers and found the hull "in overall good condition for a vessel of its age with no damages, no blisters or electrolysis observed", the haul-out of February 2021 and the drydocking four months before the casualty, the probable cause ("likely a failure of the doubler-plated hull below the engine room") and the lesson that doubler plating "is not generally suitable as a permanent repair for a vessel's hull". The report notes that uninspected fishing vessels may use doublers as permanent repairs, and quotes US Coast Guard guidance (NVIC 7-68 and CG-CVC Policy Letter 21-03) on doublers inhibiting assessment of the hull's true condition and on cropping out wasted plate and inserting new: ntsb.gov (report, PDF) and ntsb.gov (investigation). Distances in the report are nautical miles. ↩ ↩2
-
T. Keeling and P. Brookes, Minimum Steel Thicknesses for Narrowboats: A Discussion Paper, Edition 2.1 (14 November 2022), published by its authors: smallcraftservices.com (PDF). Table 2 records four inland insurers' answers on minimum thickness, given in private emails and anonymised as A to D; insurer B required 3mm Springers "to be overplated to gain insurance". The paper notes that "access to base plating is generally poor at docking facilities", makes satisfactory hammer sounding one of the conditions of its proposed 3mm minimum, says pitting can be repaired by welding to MCA and class guidance ("clean and dry the area"), and observes that for erosion or widespread pitting "various repair methods are common across the inland waterways and the surveyor is presently at liberty to select which one to follow". ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6
-
International Association of Classification Societies, Shipbuilding and Repair Quality Standard, Recommendation No. 47, Rev.10 (2021), Part B (repair quality standard for existing ships), section 6.3, Doublers on plating: "Local doublers are normally only allowed as temporary repairs". Its table asks for existing plating of at least 5mm (below that, "a permanent repair by insert is to be carried out"), rounded corners of radius 50mm or more, and slot welding for larger doublers: iacs.org.uk (PDF). It is written for ships in class, and its figures are scaled for ship plating; no rule applies it to private inland craft. ↩
-
Our worked example, on stated assumptions. 26m² × 6mm is 0.156m³ of steel; at 7,850kg/m³ (the density ArcelorMittal's section tables assume: orangebook.arcelormittal.com) that is about 1,225kg. Below the waterline the new plate displaces its own volume, 156kg of fresh water, leaving about 1,070kg to be carried. A 57ft by 6ft 10in boat (17.4m by 2.08m) with a waterplane coefficient of about 0.85 has roughly 31m² of waterplane, so 1,070kg sinks her about 3.5cm; with the 6mm plate added beneath her, she draws about 4cm more. A real boat's baseplate area and waterplane will differ, and so will the figures. ↩


